tim_donaghy.jpg

Donaghy scandal ripples through referee world - | 14:14:47
posted by: Howard Smith

This entry was written by Greg Johnson, the Associate Director of The NCAA News and Champion magazine.

The ripple effect from former NBA Referee Tim Donaghy providing inside information to gamblers on games, including ones he officiated, is larger than the league. Impartiality is the most basic rule of officiating, and the high-profile violation sent shockwaves throughout the entire sports world, including intercollegiate athletics.

I spent July 27-29 at the National Association of Sports Officials Summit in Cleveland and heard tales of youth soccer officials being criticized by parents asking if they were "on the take." The scandal broke just a week before last year's summit, where the consensus was that no matter the sentence, it wouldn't be harsh enough.

The hurt was evident everywhere you looked at NASO a year ago. Now that Donaghy has been sentenced to 15 months in jail and three years of supervised probation, sports officials at every level are trying to move forward.

Improving background checks for officials in all sports is one of the positives to emerge from this public-relations nightmare. Officials being more aware of actions by their peers and policing their own is another preventative measure.

Meeting with these men and women of NASO - who take it upon themselves to do what often is a thankless job - has been eye-opening. Not only do you see a human side of some of the top NFL, NBA and intercollegiate officials, the feeling of integrity is unmistakable.

Bob Delaney, who has worked more than 20 seasons in the NBA, held a two-hour breakout session in which he talked about the importance of plowing straight ahead through the controversy and maintaining integrity.

Delaney is also a former New Jersey state trooper, who in the mid-1970s worked undercover for three years infiltrating an organized-crime group. During his time with the state police, he saw scandals in which fellow police officers were caught breaking the law.

During those times, I imagine you go back to the basics of why you chose to be in a profession in which public trust is inherent and reflect on what to do when that trust is broken. Whether it is youth, high school, intercollegiate or professional sports, the expectation of officials is to ensure that a fair contest is conducted.

I attended a break-out session with basketball officials - again from every level - in which plays from an Ohio high school boys' state tournament game were shown. Different situations were displayed and the officials talked about why a correct call was made and why a certain call was missed.

They spoke about the responsibilities that each of the three officials had and the areas of the court they were assigned to watch. They dissected traveling calls, charge/blocks, physical play in the low post, mechanics, positioning and other plays. The attention to detail in the conversations was amazing to hear.

Nobody is on the take here. All of this healthy dialogue was done with one goal in mind: making the right call. It's an experience I'll try to keep in mind when I watch my favorite college teams next season.

Comments

Having two kids in competitive soccer at U12 and U15, I have to wonder if the refs are 'on the take' at some time too because some of them are so blatantly one-sided it's ridiculous. So... hearing that criticism from parents, I'd take that complaint as a grain of salt.

Still, I was a field marshall a couple of weeks ago for districts here in Minnesota so I got to see the game from the other side. I was asked to assist a ref who was getting blasted by a coach (parents who were getting a little rowdy would quickly settle down when the saw me come into their area).

It was an interesting experience. I'd recommend it to any parent whose kids are playing in competitive sport - get a taste of what it's like for once.

As for parent criticism towards refs... it's hard being a parent when bad calls are made - the ref in our U15 district game called a penalty resulting in a free kick then ended the half before the kick was attempted, right outside the goalie area - what sport has a half or game end on a penalty? - but I don't condone blasting officials either.

We beat them up too badly, and we won't have any who will do it anymore, and the good ones will quit anyway.

Nice article.


posted by: Jon Johnston | 07/31/08

College games have the higher probabilty of being fixed jsut due to the fact that the regulation is so much lower by Vegas, the NCAA and the conferences. I think this will become a bigger deal once a second ref is caught and a trend appears.

posted by: Brian | 08/01/08

Post a Comment


Type the characters you see in the picture above.

CommentsFeaturedRecent
It means that two very good teams with very good coaches made it to the final game.
- Marie
Read Post
Double-a Poll

footer