glenallenhill.jpg
Why Do Coaches Refuse To Wear Helmets? -
posted by: Josh

Last July, Tulsa Drillers first-base coach and father of two Mike Coolbaugh was struck in the head by a foul ball and died soon afterwards. Like all base coaches at the time, Coolbaugh wasn't wearing a helmet on the field.

Since that time, Major League Baseball has adopted a rule that requires coaches to wear helmets when they're out on the field. A lot of coaches aren't happy with the new rule, including Los Angeles Dodgers' third-base coach Larry Bowa, who said: "That's not for me. My question is, how can I be in the league 40 years and the league says who wears a helmet and who doesn't? One guy got killed and I'm sorry it happened."

Whether or not Bowa likes the new rule, however, is irrelevant, as MLB has decided that safety comes first for coaches, and helmets are now required in the boxes. But outside of the professional ranks, have we learned from last summer's incident, or are we going to wait for another tragedy to come again?

This spring, I am volunteering as a high school baseball coach. Over the weekend, I coached first for the Bishop Chatard junior-varsity team. I didn't wear a helmet at first base, although I did think about my stupidity. What prevented me from putting on something that could clearly protect me? Was it vanity? Is it my belief that I can get out of the way of anything that comes my way?

These are interesting questions. In general, I'm not a vain individual and I've been hit enough times in the face while fielding that I should know that nobody's quick enough every single time. In fact, I saw a kid get hit by a line drive, while playing first, in a college game a few years ago. The ball was right at him and he still took it right off the head. Luckily, it was just a concussion and some embarrassment for the player, but it could have been much worse.

So I guess I'm looking for rationale. Professional coaches have put helmets on while they're out on the field, yet college and high school coaches seem to have ignored last summer's tragedy with a "it can't happen to me mentality." I've been at a lot of games this spring and not once have I seen a base coach wear a helmet, myself included. We're playing with our lives, yet nobody seems overly concerned. Why is that?

I like to think that the next time I'm on the field, I'll channel John Olerud and throw a helmet on. It may not look cool, but I know that if something freaky does happen, at least I'll be able to stand back up. If Mike Coolbaugh had one more shot at it, he'd put a helmet on.

Comments

And don't forget the sunblock!

Exposure to the sun's rays when you're young can come back to haunt you decades later as melanoma, and other forms of skin cancer.

I write from experience.

While baseball can mandate helmets to protect you from batted or thrown balls, only parents' common sense can drill the use of sunblock into your game regimen.

Forewarned...

posted by: Larry | 04/28/08

Mandating helmets for MLB coaches will almost certainly help move this trend down the line to high school and college teams. Baseball has for decades maintained a hidebound, traditional culture. Nostalgia is an essential part of the game's allure, probably more so than the other major sports. When did they start playing night games at Wrigley Field?

It won't be immediate, but the only way to change unsafe traditions is at the top.

posted by: Max | 04/29/08

This is a heartfelt post, but it ignores the fact that a helmet would not have saved Mike Coolbaugh. He was hit in the neck.

The issue is likely not one of vanity, or even tradition, but one of comfort. The coach wants to focus on the game and anything that is the least bit uncomfortable can be a distraction. I'm a high-school umpire and I would prefer not to wear a hardhat, at least when working the bases.

This is the knee-jerk PR move that happens after almost any tragedy. That doesn't make it a bad thing. But it's impossible to prevent everything with a .001% chance of occurrence from happening. Wearing helmets is a commendable idea, but I guess I don't understand your disbelief as to why some people would like to see the rule be optional. It's really not that big a deal.

Plus the helmets worn in pro ball don’t have earflaps. Will we have to go thru all of this discussion again when some guy wearing the hardhat takes a line drive in the earlobe? Where does it end?

posted by: Mark Mentone | 04/29/08

There's no question, having coaches wear helmets would be a relatively cheap and easy way to significantly lower the risk of injury from a blow to the head. But it makes perfect sense that people choose not to do it. There are plenty of cheap, easy ways we could further safeguard ourselves in our daily lives--in fact, wearing helmets on the street would protect us from any number of dangers, most notably those posed by moving cars. Those risks are real, and they seem even more real after a tragedy like the one that befell Mike Coolbaugh. But those risks are also small, so we don't take the easy precautions. If we tried to defend ourselves from every risk, I suspect we wouldn't be very happy.

But I'm with Larry--we're much better off focusing not on the dramatic but miniscule risks, but on those that put millions of us in peril every day without anybody noticing.

posted by: Greg | 04/29/08

I agree that coaches should wear some type of protective head covering. I also feel that baseball needs to do a better job protecting fans from foul balls. Baseball parks are only required to protect the most dangerous part of the stadium (usually described as the area behind home plate) and have enough screened seats for those who might want them (called the limited duty rule). However, there is no proof that the backstop screens in the new "up-close" stadiums are in fact protecting the most dangerous part of the ballpark (usually down the first and third base lines) or that regular fans can obtain screened seats.
Gil Fried
Professor
University of New Haven

posted by: Gil Fried | 04/29/08

OK we have to wear them but where can we buy them. I can't find them anywhere.

posted by: dave | 04/30/08

Post a Comment

 

Type the characters you see in the picture above.

CommentsFeaturedRecent
It's a well needed wake-up call...The true test of a good/great business model is the ability to survive/thrive even in a bad economy.
- Gil Fried
Read Post
footer