I never watched the XFL, haven’t been to a CBA game and I think the National Xtreme Baseball League is beyond absurd. I think “alternative” professional leagues are a risky proposition and it’s not surprising that they rarely work.
When I first heard about the plan for the All-American Football League, I shrugged it off as another surefire failure for another group of entrepreneurs who seem to have trouble understanding that there are already plenty of sports products out there. But as I read a couple of articles about the league, and found out former NCAA President Cedric Dempsey was involved, my interest was piqued.
Instead of trying to enter the market as a B-rate version of the NFL, the AAFL is poised to offer something unique. The plan is to have eight teams in college towns across the country, games will be played on Saturdays in the spring/summer and rosters will feature players with college ties to the towns they play in. Essentially, Florida’s team will feature a number of former Gators while Alabama’s squad will surely have a number of players who used to suit up for the Crimson Tide.
While the AAFL is clearly a for-profit venture, it does have ties to education – any player on a league roster must have finished his college degree. By matching players with their alma maters and making education an important component, the league’s founders have seemingly combined core principles of both college and professional football.
Do I think the AAFL will be successful? Not really – but anything is possible. There are a lot of football junkies out there, and the opportunity to watch players from your favorite college team during the summer may find a niche I’m not anticipating. This will be an interesting one to watch.